To consolidate data you might use a PivotTable, but PivotTables mainly summarize numbers. If you need to consolidate text-only data, use Power Query — a relatively unknown but powerful new Excel tool.
♦Applicable to Office 2016 or later♦
- Select the data range
- Data → From Table/Range
- Select the Position column
- Transform → Pivot Column

- In Advanced Options: Don't aggregate
- Close & Load
- Done!















